Agranat Commission of Inquiry Interim Report (April ) il/news/politics/ Chapter 1: Preface. 1. Israel finally releases the late prime minister’s testimony before the Agranat in advance but did not properly pass information along, declassified report says. The Agranat Commission’s reports were ferociously debated on the front pages of newspapers, on radio and television, by every cab driver and shopkeeper.
The findings of the Agranat Commission have been the focus of sharp debate among the Israeli public up until today. A warning that would allow time for the orderly call up of reserves. Four months before the Agranat Commission published its first report, a commission created by US Central Intelligence head William Colby published its report citing the fixation on an incorrect concept, evidently due to General Daniel Graham.
This report caused public uproar and unhappiness in the army. Accordingly, Elazar resigned in April of The findings of the Agranat Commission notwithstanding, Dayan panicked at a crucial moment and began babbling about “the fall of the Third Temple.
Formerly, this sound was often represented by chespecially in German transliterations of Hebrew. A professor of law, Pnina Lahav has published nearly 50 journal articles and books, including the critically acclaimed Judgment in Jerusalem: I don’t have a reasonable response for this, I didn’t talk to the Aman chief, there are people who are bigger experts than me when it comes to Intel. This only confirmed the Commission’s criticisms about the reliance on a single avenue for intelligence analysis.
The official published version of the Agranat report lists three factors responsible for rfport “Mechdal” failure. Views Read Edit View history.
Meir replied, “According to Aman reports, the Syrians thought Israel was purposefully provoking them to drag them into a war. On 31 Decemberelections that had been delayed by the war took place.
Second, Zeira’s concept laid down, if there was to be a war, it would be a short one. Its headline recommendation was the dismissal of four senior officers in military intelligence: In Abba Eban ‘s words “The conclusions Our Life, His Legacy. Stubborn adherence of the intelligence heads to what was called “the concept” according to which a Egypt would not go to war against Israel, unless it could first ensure that it was able to penetrate Israeli air defenses in depth.
He was also instrumental in maintaining morale during the war. Yet vital units such as field intelligence were not called up, so that there were no updated targeting reports and it was difficult to provide air support for battles in the Golan Heights. As is true of the second report, its contents were heavily censored and inaccessible to the general public.
The lack of definition of responsibilities that is current in the area of defense, an area second to none in critical importance, makes effective action difficult, detracts from focusing legal authority and even causes lack of clarity and confusion in the public Though they had the ability to launch a limited war, they knew perfectly well that Israel would not feel itself bound by the rules of that game, and a limited war would quickly escalate into a general one.
Dayan in the Yom Kippur War Photo: The report was published at various levels of secrecy and only a part of it was made public.
Aman believed, she added, that the Syrians would not act alone, but rather with Egypt, and that the drill was for protective purposes.
Sorry, your browser doesn’t support frames…
Marwan has wrongly been cast as a Mossad agent in several sources, but he was not. On July 10,a second interim report was issued. Yadin continued, asking if it was okay that Zamir didn’t tell Meir before he left. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
Likewise the Agranat Commission determined that “It is essential that the Prime Minister have access to policy, military and qgranat evaluations that are collated and based on different points of view and do not come from a singe pipeline. Meir criticized the defense minister. After his dismissal, Elazar maintained that had he been given more of the information, he would have mobilized the IDF sooner.
Israeli commissions and inquiries Yom Kippur War. Despite the severe oversight, Meir supported Aman in her testimony. Golda Meir protocols from Agranat Agrannat released.
In Repprt there are several letters that have similar sounds.
Every Israeli had—still has—a definite opinion about its findings. This conception, which was based on some inflexible principles, prevented the evaluation and analysis of relevant intelligence information, that had arrived from various intelligence sources and warned explicitly of the dangers of war.
Israeli Military in politics. Dayan bears direct responsibility for ordering the air force to turn back on its way to attacking on the Sinai front, in order to execute an ineffectual attack on the Syrian front.
The second part was published 10 July and contained the reasons for the conclusions of the first report. In the absence of any upgrading of Egypt’s air force, the directorate concluded there was no threat of imminent war. The Agranat Commission found that there was lack of clarity regarding the specific responsibilities for national security of the Prime Minister, the Minister of Defense and the Chief of Staff, “From the constitutional standpoint, it was never defined if the Minister of Defense is a kind of super chief of staff who must provide guidance to the Chief of Staff in his responsibility in the operative area, or of repogt is actually the supreme commander of the Agramat in his capacity as minister of defense.
Further criticism responds to the Commission’s recommendations, stemming from the failure of military intelligence to assess the Arab states’ intent, that the IDF should not consider the intentions of hostile replrt, but rather their capacity for war.
Gordon, Samuel, 30 Hours in October: Despite predictions that the north is staying calm, war over missiles looms large on the horizon; and Hamas shows it can still undermine Israel even with its tunnels exposed. November 12, As Israel marks 40 years since its traumatic war, all agrana are on Syria and its chemical weapons.
It has not functioned properly however.
Publication of the report led to the resignation of Zeira from the army. An Anatomy of the State. There was no chance of destroyed the Egyptian air force on the ground. Its main clause stated:.
Many of the conclusions and hearings of the Agranat Commission were agranaat fully declassified for many years, and perhaps some are still classified. Meir had no combat experience or understanding of military strategy.